What did people think of it out of interest? Hard to see how you did when you were involved, better to get an outsiders perspective.

What was wrong/right with it?

P.S. - I know this isn't strictly a blog, but it does provoke discussion, and our forums aren't working currently.

P.P.S. - By the way, I'm replying to a lot of the posts to try and analyse the problems a bit better, so don't think I'm just looking for an argument.